Third Eye Capital
Tel: (416) 601-2270
Fax: (416) 981-3393
Email Third Eye Capital

Brookfield Place
Bay Wellington Tower
181 Bay Street, Suite 2830
Toronto, Ontario, M5J 2T3

CEO Insights

CEO Insights

Knowing the Value of Everything but the Price of Nothing (Q3-12)

Knowing the Value of Everything but the Price of Nothing (Q3-12)

Edward Francis Hutton, the American financier who founded the eponymous brokerage firm E.F. Hutton in 1906, was revered for his ability to consistently buy assets on the cheap. On one occasion, while searching for land in the south to hunt on, he found a plantation named Hickory Hill for sale. After concluding a deal to purchase the property, Hutton said to the former owner, “Mr. Ravenel, it’s been nice knowing you, but you’re about the poorest businessman I know. I would have paid you twice the price for that land.” To which Ravenel said, smiling “I would have sold it for half as much.”

Valuation is highly subjective, even when there is a determined price. That is because as individuals, we make valuation judgments based on time, context, and our own unique perspective. It may be theoretically expedient to apply fuzzy mathematical models that generate seemingly precise value estimates, but failing to appreciate the subjectivity of valuation can be dangerous.

Take the example of the “expert appraisal”. The expert will apply various quantitative approaches to measuring value of an asset, including (i) determining the costs incurred to develop a similar asset, also known as cost-based value; (ii) observing prices of comparable assets traded between parties, also known as market-based value; and (iii) computing the present value of future cash flows of the asset over its useful life, also known as income-based value. Each of these approaches relies on assumptions of the expert and inputs that are subjective and uncertain. The expert retained will usually have direct experience in trading the asset or representing relevant industry buyers and sellers in similar transactions for which the appraisal is used. However, using an expert appraisal privileges the biases and assumptions of the expert over others, and the notion that the expert’s determination of value is “better” is purely theoretical.

Lenders rely on expert appraisals to determine the value of their security, a process that has become more heavily scrutinized in the aftermath of the financial crisis when many lenders learned the difficult lesson that realized prices can deviate substantially from appraised values. Asset appraisals are generally considered by lenders to be an insurance policy for their credit decisions, and are therefore used more frequently in lending situations that are collateral-dependent, such as for asset-based loans and during distress, default, or impairment. Of course, it is in situations like these that such an insurance policy will most likely have to provide cover, and the expert appraisal may be the lender’s best hope for an objective valuation.

The expert appraisal can be helpful but it ignores the perspectives, circumstances, and risk thresholds that are unique to the individuals making the choices. Time, context, and perspective are dynamic factors, and can quickly render an expert appraisal to be a utopian standard of value that is difficult to achieve. Trying to handicap the value of an asset is one of the biggest challenges faced by lenders today, especially since many companies’ most critical assets are intangible or even invisible on a balance sheet. We consider expert appraisals to be a proxy measure that establishes a mere starting point for estimating value. Expert appraisals should be the result of a lending decision, not the other way around. We develop real-world scenarios reflecting specific buyer behavior to determine the price that will be ultimately paid for our collateral assets, and update these scenarios on a periodic basis. We do this through discussions with liquidators, suppliers, competitors, and consumers of the assets being valued. This incorporates the factors of time, context, and perspective into our analysis, which can avoid us subjugating to the subjectivity of experts.

Value and price are rarely the same, but recognizing that value is unique and subjective can free lenders from the abstractions and models of expert appraisals, and achieve collateral price estimates that are married to reality. Lenders face a myriad of challenges and properly valuing assets should not be one of them.

Excerpted from Third Eye Capital Management Inc.’s Q3 2012 Investor Letter.



Domestic (Canadian) Advisor registration form:

If you are an advisor that distributes or is interested in distributing a fund advised by Third Eye Capital Management Inc. you can register to request a call or meeting. You will be asked to provide information to confirm your qualifications to invest in or distribute the funds. This brief registration process allows us to conform to applicable securities laws and to obtain some basic information about you. Once we have qualified and approved your registration, we will get in contact with you to schedule a meeting.

    Personal Information

    I consent to receive information from Third Eye Capital.

    Domestic (Canadian) Investor registration form:

    If you are an existing or prospective accredited investor that distributes or is interested in distributing a fund advised by Third Eye Capital Management Inc. you can register to request a call or meeting. You will be asked to provide information to confirm your qualifications to invest in or distribute the funds. This brief registration process allows us to conform to applicable securities laws and to obtain some basic information about you. Once we have qualified and approved your registration, we will get in contact with you to schedule a meeting.

      Personal Information

      YesNo
      I consent to receive information from Third Eye Capital.

      International Investor registration form:

      For US persons
      If you are an existing or prospective accredited investor or an advisor that distributes or is interested in distributing a fund advised by Third Eye Capital Management Inc. you can register to request a call or meeting. You will be asked to provide information to confirm your qualifications to invest in or distribute the funds. This brief registration process allows us to conform to applicable securities laws and to obtain some basic information about you. Once we have qualified and approved your registration, we will get in contact with you to schedule a meeting.

        Personal Information

        I consent to receive information from Third Eye Capital.

        Address Information

        Investor Information

        An IndividualA Company
        U.S.Other (specify)
        Fund of FundsFamily OfficeBankOther (specify)
        $

        Instructions for the following sections: Individuals please answer Part A of Sections I and II; Institutions please have an authorized person answer Part B of Sections I and II.

        Section I - Accredited Investor Threshold Questions:

        Part A - For Individuals:

        1. I certify that I have an individual net worth, or my spouse and I have a combined net worth in excess of $1,000,000.

        2. I certify that I am highly a sophisticated investor who routinely invests sums of $250,000 or more.

        Part B - For Institutions:

        1. The submitter certifies that it is a bank, insurance company, registered investment company, business development company, or small business investment company.

        2. The submitter certifies that it is a charitable organization, corporation or partnership with assets exceeding $5 million, and that was not formed to invest the Fund.

        3. The submitter certifies that it is a corporation, partnership or trust with assets of at least $5 million, that was not formed to invest in the Fund, and whose purchases are directed by a sophisticated person.

        4. The undersigned certifies that all of its equity owners are “accredited investors” as defined in United States Securities and Exchange Commission Rule 501(a) and who can satisfy the higher criteria for the same set forth in Section I, Part A above.

        Section II - Qualified Purchaser Questions:

        Part A - For Individuals:

        1. I certify that I own not less than $1,000,000 in securities investments.

        Part B - For Institutions:

        1. The undersigned certifies that it is a bank, insurance company, registered investment company, business development company, or small business investment company

        2. The undersigned certifies that it is a "family owned company" (as defined below) that owns not less than $5,000,000 in securities investments. A "family owned company" is defined as a company that is owned directly or indirectly by or for two or more natural persons who are related as siblings or spouse (including former spouses), or direct lineal descendents by birth or adoption, spouses of such persons, the estate of such persons, or foundations, charitable organizations, or trust established by or for the benefit of such persons

        3. The undersigned certifies that it is a trust that was not formed to invest in the Fund, the trustee or decision-making authority of which, and every person contributing assets to the same, is a “Qualified Purchaser” under one of the other definitions of this Section

        4. The undersigned certifies that it is a person acting for its own account or for the accounts of other Qualified Purchasers who in the aggregate own and invest on a discretionary basis at least $5,000,000 in securities investments.

        Questionnaire Submission:

        Thank you for your patience in completing this questionnaire.

        If you have any questions, please contact Chris Vokes, VP of Investor Relations at Third Eye Capital:

        T 416-601-2270 ext 242
        E chris@thirdeyecapital.com